Inflation Much Worse than Deflation

According to The Alpha Strategy, which in my opinion is one of the greatest books on investing ever in the world, there are three things one can do to preserve purchasing power: lending, investing, and buying.

Lending includes keeping money in a bank account since you are lending it to the bank and the bank pays interest for this privilege. It also includes buying government bonds, which effectively is lending money to the government. Investing refers to owning a business and sharing in the profits of that business. Investing includes actually starting your own company or buying shares. Buying refers to buying actual tangible things like gold or land.

There are two major problems with lending: inflation and taxation. When you lend money, the money you receive back is taxed, which eats away into any profits you could make. Another problem is that inflation eats away at purchasing power. If you keep $100 in the bank and get $103 at the end of the year in interest, inflation running at 3 per cent per year means that you are no better off by putting your money in the bank.

Lending then is only good when there is deflation. The problem with investing for deflation is that deflation tends not to happen often, mainly because government is so scared of deflation that they will do what they can to prevent it, which means that they are willing to create inflation, even though inflation hurts people by reducing the purchasing power of their wealth.

Inflation can be seen as good because inflation motivates people to work hard and spend. With the price of everything going up due to inflation, people are forced to work even harder and harder in order to afford to live. If the state is seen as an apparatus of slavery then government-induced inflation is the way that the slave owners (the government) can whip (create inflation) his slaves (the citizens) in order to get them to work.

Assuming you are able to keep your job in a deflationary recession (not a realistic assumption for most jobs) then deflation is not a bad thing because the price of goods goes down. Because deflation is not a major disaster and because it is rare, I think that it pays to not devote so much of your wealth to preparing for deflation.

Many financial advisers talk about risk tolerance and asset allocation. Asset allocation refers to the percentages you devote to certain types of investments, mainly stocks and bonds/cash, i.e. how much you will invest and how much you will lend. If you are willing to take on more risk, you invest more in stocks and if you are more of a conservative investors, you invest more in bonds/cash. In my opinion, because inflation is so much worse than deflation (because prices of things go up), then it's better to devote a little more to assets that keep up with inflation (stocks, gold, and real estate) rather than assets that do well during periods of deflation (bonds and cash).

Based on my gut-feel analysis of the world economy at the moment--during this period of "unusual uncertainty," as Bernanke described it--I believe that you should hold about 60% in stocks, 30% bonds or cash, and 10% gold.

Image: Tao Zhyn

Double-Dip is Here! Prepare for a Deflationary Depression

It's not looking good for the world economy!

The American market has just tanked 3 per cent in a day and Nouriel Roubini is calling a double-dip recession. I am really worried because I have about 75% of my wealth exposed to the stock market and I just know the stock market will tank. I was close to 100% in stocks during the recovery after the GFC, hoping to take advantage of the stimulus-fueled recovery--and it worked out well!--but for the last seven months I've been worried about a double dip recession and have gone into cash and bonds, but unfortunately it seems like I could not buy cash and bonds fast enough. In desperation, I am thinking of selling stocks in my retirement fund, which should see my overall stock market exposure reduced to 60% which I think is reasonable. The only problem with this is that switching investments in your retirement fund is not a quick process and may take a fortnight. Between now and next fortnight, a lot can happen in the financial markets.

Inflation vs Deflation

For a little less than a year now the stock market has been going sideways. That is, it has gone up and then down, but the net effect is sideways. The All Ords chart below from Yahoo! illustrates this. Since September 2009, the Australian stock market has been going up and down, bounching back and forth between a ceiling of 5000 and a floor of 4500.

However, recently we have seen the stock market start to plunge below the 4500 point floor, suggesting that a dreaded double-dip recession may be just around the corner. Chinese premier Wen Jiabao warned that a double-dip recession was likely, and billionaire investor George Soros claimed that the second phase of the GFC was imminent.

This may be it!

For the last few days of the 2009-10 financial year, stocks all over the world have been tumbling. On 1 July 2010, the price of gold collapsed from US$1250 per ounce to US$1200 per ounce, and at the same time long-term US Treasury bonds have gone up in price. All this points to investors expecting deflation in the future. That is, prices are going to fall. Some people who complain about high petrol and electricity prices may be happy with this, but deflation may result in falls in stock prices and real estate prices, and this will destroy wealth, especially since many people hold wealth in their houses and their retirement funds. Economic theory also states that falling prices encourage consumers to horde cash and delay purchases becuase they expect goods to be cheaper in the future. This hording of cash and lack of spending will reduce sales, reduce business profits, and in turn lead to higher unemployment or lower wages, which will reduce demand for goods even further as consumers who have their wages cut cannot afford to buy goods. This will lead to even more price cutting by businesses, which leads to a vicious cycle or a deflationary spiral. As people lose jobs and suffer from wage cuts, they cannot afford to buy houses and the many who already suffer from mortgage stress will default. This is a nightmare economic situation.

On the other hand, there are those who believe that deflation will not happen. They claim that because deflation is so nightmarish, the government will not allow it because the government wants to win votes. Rather, the government will continue to simulate the economy by giving away cash. Splashing cash into the economy will increase wages and increase stock prices and real estate prices. Inflation will especially increase gold prices. I have my doubts about this inflation story because splashing cash into the economy cannot last forever. Eventually the government will run out of money and will have to go into debt, which is what we are seeing in Greece. Voters surely will not support neverending increases in public debt, and lenders (i.e. bondholders) will not tolerate it. The demands of voters and lenders should force governments with high public debts to impliment austerity measures that cut spending and raise taxes. Tax increases will retard economy growth, which pushes down stock prices.

If you think inflation is likely, go into stocks and gold. If you think deflation is likely, go into cash and bonds. If you are unsure, equal amounts of all four is probably the best move.